Rafe's POV
I don't answer her.
I can't.
I drive us home at twenty miles an hour, the long way, up through Richmond Park in the dark, so I don't have to pass that oak tree. I text my head of investment to make my apologies at Haldane's. Food poisoning. He replies with a thumbs-up and the sum of money I've probably just lost.
I don't care.
Isla sits beside me with her eyes closed and her hands knotted in her lap, rain dripping from the ends of her hair. She doesn't say another word.
Neither do I.
But her question rides with us the whole way.
Why didn't you answer?
***
At midnight I open the safe in my study.
I haven't touched the trial file in eighteen months. It lives at the back, behind the deeds to the house and my father's watch, in four fat ring binders with blue spines.
R v Marlowe.
I pour a whisky, sit down at my desk, and open the first one.
I tell myself I'm doing it to prove her wrong.
I read until three.
Her police interview. The phone records: Poppy's mobile, two outgoing calls to my number at 23:41 and 23:43, both unanswered. I'd known that. I'd read it a hundred times. I'd never once let myself picture who was holding the phone.
The collision investigator's report. Vehicle travelling at an estimated 68 mph. Loss of control on a left-hand bend. Impact with an oak tree. Fire originating in the engine compartment.
A line I'd skimmed before.
Damage to the rear offside of the vehicle is consistent with secondary contact with the boundary wall during rotation.
Consistent with.
Not proven. Just consistent.
I read the defence's response. Their expert had said the rear damage was equally consistent with being struck from behind. The prosecution had dismissed it. No paint transfer was recovered. The fire had destroyed too much.
I keep reading.
The firefighters' statements. The deceased was found lying on the grass approximately four metres from the vehicle. The driver was kneeling beside her. The driver's clothing was alight across the shoulders and back. The driver resisted attempts to move her away from the deceased.
I stop.
I read that line again.
The driver's clothing was alight.
I'd known she pulled Poppy out. Everyone knew. The prosecution barrister had turned it against her in his closing speech. A guilty conscience, members of the jury. The instinct of a woman who knew exactly what she had done.
I'd nodded along in the public gallery. I'd thought it was clever.
Then the medical report.
Partial and full-thickness burns to both forearms and hands, and across the upper back and shoulders. Pattern consistent with prolonged exposure while reaching into or leaning over a burning vehicle.
Prolonged.
She didn't just open a door and pull.
She was in that fire long enough for her back to catch light.
I close the binder.
My hands aren't steady. I put them flat on the desk and look at them.
Hands tell you everything about a person.
***
Julian arrives at nine on Saturday morning with coffee and croissants, the way he has every Saturday since the funeral.
He takes one look at the binders spread across my desk and sets the coffee down slowly.
"Oh, Rafe," he says. "No."
"I'm just reading."
"You're torturing yourself." He picks up the top binder, flicks through it, and puts it down again. "Why now?"
I tell him about Petersham Road. About the panic attack. About the scars.
I don't tell him about the phone calls. I can't make the words come out.
Julian listens with his arms folded, nodding slowly.
"Of course she has scars," he says when I've finished. "She was in a car that caught fire. That doesn't make her innocent. It makes her lucky."
"The burns are on her back, Jules. She was leaning into the fire."
"So she pulled Poppy out after she'd crashed into a tree at nearly seventy miles an hour." He spreads his hands. "Good for her. That's what any human being would do. It doesn't change why they were in that tree in the first place."
He's right.
I know he's right.
"She's clever," he says gently. "You told me yourself, she was calm as anything in court. And now she's living under your roof, sleeping in Poppy's bed, and she's found exactly where to press. She knows the one thing you'd do anything to believe."
He lays a hand on my shoulder.
"That it wasn't anyone's fault," he says. "Least of all yours."
I flinch.
He squeezes my shoulder, then lets go. His eyes drift back to the binders.
"Want me to take these off your hands for a while?" he offers lightly. "Lock them in my office. Save you from yourself."
"No," I say. "I'll put them away."
Something flickers in his face. Then he smiles and pushes a coffee across the desk towards me.
"Your call," he says.
***
On Sunday morning, Isla knocks on my study door.
It's the first time she's spoken to me since Friday.
"I'd like to go for a walk," she says. "On my own. For an hour."
The rules say she has to ask. She's asking.
"Where?"
She hesitates. "Just down the hill."
I could say no.
"Fine," I say.
I give her ten minutes' head start.
Then I put on my coat and follow her.
I'm not proud of it.
She walks fast, with her head down and her hands in her pockets. Down the steep footpath beside the terrace gardens. Along the river towards Petersham, where the meadow is silver with dew and cows stand steaming in the cold.
She's carrying something wrapped in brown paper.
I already know where she's going before she turns through the lychgate of St Peter's Church.
My parents are buried in that churchyard.
So is Poppy.
I stop by the yew hedge, out of sight, and watch my wife walk between the old gravestones to the white marble one at the end. She kneels in the wet grass. She unwraps the brown paper.
White lilies.
Her hands move carefully, taking out last week's flowers, putting the new ones in the stone vase. She touches the letters of Poppy's name with her fingertips. She bows her head.
I can't breathe.
Every Sunday for two and a half years, I've come to this grave and found fresh white lilies in that vase.
Every single week.
I thought they were from Saskia. Or the university. Or some kind stranger who'd read about Poppy in the papers.
But Isla was in prison for two of those years.
So who...
"Mr Calloway?"
I turn. The vicar, an elderly woman in a green anorak, is coming along the path with a watering can. She follows my gaze and smiles.
"Oh, that's lovely," she says softly. "She's come herself at last."
"At last?"
"Her brother brought them while she was away," the vicar says. "Every Sunday, rain or shine. A skinny lad, very polite." She pats my arm. "He told me his sister had paid for a whole year of lilies at a time, out of her savings and whatever she could earn inside. She made him promise never to miss a week."
She walks on.
And I stand there in the wet grass, watching the woman I married to destroy kneel at my sister's grave, and I feel the ground I've built my whole life on for two and a half years begin to crack.